Categories
Uncategorized

Peace Deals? The Bible Forbids Them.

The Torah’s prohibition against dealing with the locals reads:

Beware of making a covenant (tichrot brit) with the inhabitants of the land against which you are advancing, lest they be a snare (mokesh) in your midst. (E.34:12 (Exodus 34:12)) … You must not make a covenant (tichrot brit) with the inhabitants of the land, for they will lust after (vezanu) their gods and sacrifice (vezavchu) to their gods and invite you (vekara lecha), and you will eat of their sacrifices (ve’achalta mizivcho). And when you take… from among their daughters (mibnotav) for your sons, their daughters will lust after their gods and will cause your sons to lust after their gods. (E.34:15 (Exodus 34:15), 16 (Exodus 34:16))

Every piece of this prohibition (we’ll refer to it as “the prohibition” for the rest of this piece) – a covenant, a feast, a sacrifice, an invitation, daughters, and their gods – was lived first by our forefathers, in their deals with non-Jews: Avraham and Yitzchak with Avimelech, Yaakov with Lavan, and Yaakov’s family with Shechem. The prohibition is the lesson of those linguistically linked deals, transformed into law.1

A covenant between people

The phrase “cut a covenant” (karat brit) describes a pact between human beings in only three episodes in the entire Torah: Avraham with Avimelech (G.21:27 (Genesis 21:27), 32 (Genesis 21:32)), Yitzchak with Avimelech (G.26:28 (Genesis 26:28)), and Yaakov with Lavan (G.31:44 (Genesis 31:44)). The only other mentions in the Torah of “cut a covenant,” karat brit between people are when the Torah forbids these covenants! (E.23:32 (Exodus 23:32), E.34:12 (Exodus 34:12), 15 (Exodus 34:15), D.7:2 (Deuteronomy 7:2)). When Lavan and Jacob separate, Lavan proposes: “Come, then, let us make a pact (nichrata brit), you and I” (G.31:44 (Genesis 31:44)) – the same two words as the prohibition’s “You must not make a covenant (tichrot brit)” (E.34:15 (Exodus 34:15)). The Torah specifically forbids the covenants our forefathers made!2

The pact with Lavan: the prohibition’s script

Lavan’s pact shares more of the prohibition’s roots than any other story: karat brit (cut a covenant), zavach (sacrifice), kara (invite), achal (eat), lakach (take), daughters and sons, leading to idolatry. In the prohibition, as in Lavan’s pact, the covenant and the daughters come as one package.

The sacrifice, the invitation, the meal. The story:

Jacob then offered up a sacrifice (vayizbach zevach) on the Height, and invited (vayikra) his kinsmen to partake of the meal (le’echol lechem). (G.31:54 (Genesis 31:54))

Put the two verses side by side. At Lavan’s pact, Yaakov does three things: he sacrifices (vayizbach), he invites (vayikra), and they eat (vayochlu) (G.31:54 (Genesis 31:54)). The prohibition, which the Torah gives us in the wilderness describes the same three steps, in the same order – with the roles reversed: they sacrifice (vzavchu), they invite you (vekara lecha), and you eat (ve’achalta) (E.34:15 (Exodus 34:15)). The link: the same three roots: zavach (זבח), kara (קרא) and achal (אכל). The prohibition is Lavan’s covenant meal, seen from the other side of the table. In all of Genesis, the root zavach (sacrifice, as opposed to the altar, mizbe’ach) appears in only two verses: here, and Yaakov’s offering at Beer-sheba (G.46:1 (Genesis 46:1)), where no meal is mentioned. So Lavan’s pact is the only sacrificial meal in Genesis. “Invite” joined to eating or to sacrifices appears in only two verses in the entire Torah: Lavan’s pact, and Baal Peor (N.25:2 (Numbers 25:2)), where the prohibition’s description of what happens when you consort with the locals becomes the reality.

The daughters. The prohibition: it moves from the covenant (E.34:15 (Exodus 34:15)) straight to marriage: “you take (velakachta)… from among their daughters (mibnotav) for your sons” (E.34:16 (Exodus 34:16)). The story: Lavan’s pact does the same. “The daughters are my daughters (benotai),” he says (G.31:43 (Genesis 31:43)), and his one condition is about them: “If you ill-treat my daughters or take (tikach) other wives besides my daughters” (G.31:50 (Genesis 31:50)). The link: in the prohibition, as in Lavan’s pact, the covenant and the daughters come as one package.

Shechem: where the deal leads

Shechem has no covenant (brit) and no meal. But the Shechem story shares the prohibition’s other roots – the inhabitants of the land, dwelling, taking daughters, and whoring – almost item by item. Hamor’s offer is the prohibition in reverse:

  • Intermarriage: “Intermarry with us (vehitchatnu): give your daughters to us, and take our daughters for yourselves” (G.34:9 (Genesis 34:9)).
  • A named nation: Hamor is “the Hivite” (G.34:2 (Genesis 34:2)); the Hivites are named in the prohibition (E.34:11 (Exodus 34:11)).
  • The inhabitants of the land: Shechem’s offer is to dwell (yashav) together: “You will dwell among us” (G.34:10 (Genesis 34:10)); “we will dwell among you” (G.34:16 (Genesis 34:16)) – while the Torah says “They shall not remain (yeshvu) in your land, lest (pen) they cause you to sin against Me” (E.23:33 (Exodus 23:33)).
  • Taking daughters: “take (tikchu) our daughters (benoteinu) for yourselves” (G.34:9 (Genesis 34:9)); “we will take (nikach) their daughters to ourselves as wives” (G.34:21 (Genesis 34:21)). The exchange of daughters is repeated three times (G.34:9 (Genesis 34:9), 16 (Genesis 34:16), 21 (Genesis 34:21)) – the prohibition’s “you take (velakachta)… from among their daughters” (E.34:16 (Exodus 34:16)). The verb hitchaten (התחתן) appears in only two verses in the Torah: here, and in the prohibition – “You shall not intermarry with them: do not give your daughters to their sons or take their daughters for your sons” (D.7:3 (Deuteronomy 7:3)).
  • Whoring: “Should our sister be treated like a whore (kezonah)?” (G.34:31 (Genesis 34:31)) – the first appearance in the Torah of the root zanah (זנה), which the prohibition uses twice for “lust after” (vezanu) (E.34:15 (Exodus 34:15), 16 (Exodus 34:16)).

The Shechem story presages the prohibition. A deal with the locals, built on exchanging daughters, brings deceit (bemirmah) (G.34:13 (Genesis 34:13)), whoring and foreign gods – the very chain the prohibition warns about.

Genesis shows outsiders taking our women, and outsiders offering us theirs, in order to lead us astray. The prohibition closes the circle: do not take their women – because it leads to idolatry. “For they will turn your children away from Me to worship other gods” (D.7:4 (Deuteronomy 7:4)).

But didn’t the pacts of the forefathers end in peace? Yitzchak’s guests “departed from him in peace” (G.26:31 (Genesis 26:31)). But these were the men of whom Yitzchak said, “you have been hostile to me and have driven me away from you” (G.26:27 (Genesis 26:27)); and Jacob says that Lavan “would have sent me away empty-handed” (G.31:42 (Genesis 31:42)). These pacts needed oaths, witnesses and a mound of stones precisely because the partners could not be trusted. Although the forefathers survived these deals, we are clearly commanded not to repeat them.

Instead of seeing idol worship as the outcome, consider how Jews in Israel today accept, adopt, and eventually advocate the anti-semitic ideology of our enemies. This is where we get Jews who would rather cooperate with Arabs and Muslims than with our own people. The Torah bars us from intermarriage, intercultural cooperation, and – yes – peace deals.

P.S. The prohibition is itself a preview of what happens later – the fulfilment of the promise, almost word for word, in the incident with Baal Peor.

… the menfolk profaned themselves by whoring (liznot) with the Moabite women, who invited (vatikrena) the menfolk to the sacrifices (zivchei) for their god. The menfolk partook (vayochal) of them and worshiped that god. (N.25:1 (Numbers 25:1), 2 (Numbers 25:2))

Whoring, inviting, sacrifices, eating, their god: (E.34:15 (Exodus 34:15), 16 (Exodus 34:16)) come true. And of course, we see it in leftist Jews in Israel today.

All the links (including those not cited above), summarized


1 The word-by-word links are collected in a table at the end of this piece. ↩
2 Every remaining karat brit – 13 verses in all – is a covenant with G-d, beginning with Avram (G.15:18 (Genesis 15:18)). The patriarchs’ pacts are reported without praise; the only covenants the Torah praises are with G-d. And 13 is the number of our souls’ connection with G-d, as per Recharging the Soul. ↩

Exodus 34:12; Exodus 34:15; Exodus 23:32; Deuteronomy 7:2; Genesis 21:27; Genesis 21:32; Genesis 26:28; Genesis 31:44; Genesis 24:6; Genesis 31:24; Genesis 34:30; Exodus 23:33; Genesis 34:10; Genesis 34:16; Exodus 34:16; Genesis 34:31; Numbers 25:1; Genesis 31:30; Genesis 31:53; Genesis 35:2; Numbers 25:2; Genesis 31:54; Genesis 26:30; Genesis 29:23; Genesis 31:50; Genesis 34:2; Genesis 34:9; Genesis 34:21; Genesis 24:3; Genesis 24:4; Genesis 12:15; Genesis 12:19; Genesis 20:2; Genesis 20:3; Genesis 31:43; Genesis 24:7; Genesis 24:38; Genesis 24:40; Exodus 34:11; Deuteronomy 7:3; Exodus 34:10; Genesis 21:23; Genesis 26:29; Exodus 34:5; Genesis 21:33; Genesis 26:25; Genesis 12:8; Genesis 13:4; Exodus 34:14; Genesis 26:14.

Comments are welcome!